Wednesday, November 26, 2025

50 Pointers - Medieval-Like Fantasy Worlds - First Part

What is the key reason behind the recent surge in popularity of science fiction and fantasy genres? The authors can reveal truths about society and politics when direct expression is suppressed by an unfavorable political and religious environment. Science fiction genre is a mirror image of fantasy (sword & sorcery) established from current time reference. The book is science fiction is when you're depressed about the future, fantasy is when you're depressed about the past, and literature is when you're depressed about the present.  Similarly, fantasy is when the technology the characters use is magic and sci-fi is when the magic the characters use is technology.

Common fantasy themes that readers easily recognize include resistance to tyranny, prophecies guiding destinies, hero-centered stories, journey to distant land and rags-to-riches journeys. I will not help the readers on these familiar themes of struggle, hope, and love that form the backbone of many beloved fantasy worlds. To create a rich and believable fantasy world, author can take inspiration from real-world examples and weave them into your story. The author has to make sure all these elements fit naturally with the culture, technology, and magic of your world. This helps readers feel like they are genuinely entering a new and exciting place. 


This first exploration contains 25 pointers for the foundational elements that give fantasy worlds believability and depth upon which all other elements of your fantasy world must rest: 

1. Geography: Start with creating map of the imagined land. Natural features such as mountains, rivers, deserts, and forests will shape political boundaries, defense strategies, and trade routes. For instance, mountainous and fragmented terrain like in Greece led to decentralized city-states.  Inca Empire (South America) stretched across diverse Andean terrain—from coastal deserts to high plateaus to rainforests—requiring strategic administrative centers like Cusco positioned to oversee these distinct regions. These geographical realities drive everything: where cities can flourish, which territories can be defended, where trade routes must inevitably concentrate.

2. Primary Occupation:  In a fantasy world, primary occupations could include agriculture, animal husbandry, mining, hunting, weaving, trading, and mercenary work. These occupations reflect a balance of survival, economy, and social structure that makes the fantasy world feel authentic and lively.  Access to fertile land and water resources will be vital for any conflict situation in the book. 

3. Climate Change: Dependence on rains made kingdoms vulnerable to droughts, floods, famines, and crop failures, which could lead to widespread peasant distress and riots, as variability in rainfall and soil degradation often intensified social and economic crises. The Mali and Songhai empires faced periodic droughts and floods that devastated the Niger River region, causing famine and peasant revolts.

4. Administrative Systems: Kingdoms had centralized or decentralized political structures with feudal lords or chieftains often wielding significant autonomy, sometimes undermining royal authority and complicating efforts to establish unified governance under evolving written laws and taxation systems. The Inca maintained a highly centralized bureaucracy with the Sapa Inca as absolute ruler, dividing the empire (Tawantinsuyu) into four provinces (suyus) governed by appointed regional governors (Apus), often family members. By contrast, the Mali Empire operated with more decentralized authority, where regional kingdoms retained autonomy while acknowledging the Mali emperor's supremacy. 

5. Feudal Loyalty and Betrayal: Feudal bonds were complex, where loyalty could be bought or broken, with vassals switching allegiances based on personal gain, fear, or ambition. The Balkans saw constant vassalage shifts, with Serbian and Bulgarian kingdoms oscillating between Ottoman and Habsburg allegiances.

6. Court Politics: Noble lords jostled for influence in the royal court, with competing princes and their mothers vying for power, alliances shifting frequently and making the court a hotbed of intrigue and betrayal. Rulers often prioritized family honor and petty rivalries over collective welfare, leading to disunity and weakening alliances among kingdoms, making them vulnerable to outside enemies. In Ottoman courts (Balkans), competing princes and their mothers orchestrated elaborate intrigues for power. The Delhi Sultanate saw frequent court conspiracies, with generals and nobles assassinating sultans and installing puppet rulers.

7Wealth Spendings: Extravagance of ruling elites and political instability drained royal treasuries, reducing resources available for effective administration and military defense, weakening the kingdom's ability to respond to external threats. The Ottoman sultans (Balkans) maintained expensive imperial harems and palace hierarchies that strained state budgets.

8. Wealth Distribution: Wealth was concentrated in aristocratic landowners and temples, with limited economic growth; trade disruptions often affected royal revenues and governance capacity, while administrative reforms created tensions among citizens regarding the fairness of taxation and resource allocation. Chinese dynasties concentrated wealth among imperial family, bureaucrats, and landowners, creating resentment among peasants and merchants excluded from trade monopolies.

9. Dependency on Astrologers and Sacrifices for Key Decisions: Major state affairs, including battles and coronations, relied heavily on diviners and rituals to legitimize rulers and appease perceived supernatural forces, with kinship and lineage being the core of authority claims. Indian rajas consulted court Brahmins for auspicious planetary alignments before major decisions.

10Gender Roles and Power: While patriarchal, some kingdoms allowed women significant behind-the-scenes influence or rare direct political power, shaping plots of intrigue. Islamic Caliphates witnessed powerful women wielding influence through palace networks—mothers of caliphs, wives with access to treasure, and concubines gathering intelligence.  In Imperial China, eunuchs managed the imperial household and were involved in state affairs, often wielding significant political power. 

11. Trade Dominated by a Class Causing Resentment: Trade and commerce were often controlled by merchant classes or minority groups, sometimes causing resentment among the land-owning aristocracy and peasants. Ancient families often clashed to secure monopolies over trade, turning legacy into a battlefield of dominance. In Mali, the merchant class (often Mandinka speakers and Muslim traders) monopolized the trans-Saharan gold and salt trade, while indigenous animist populations resented their commercial dominance and Islamic conversion pressure.

12. Currency: Early forms of money included commodity money and metal bars; coinage facilitated trade and taxation but also wealth concentration. Mali minted its own gold coins and used commodity money (gold dust, salt bars) for large transactions. Chinese dynasties used both coins and paper money, with counterfeiting severe punishments.

13. Legal Systems and Corruption: Justice could be brutal, arbitrary and corrupt, with trial by ordeal or combat accepted as legitimate. Mali's Islamic legal system (Sharia) was administered by qadis (Islamic judges) appointed by the ruler, creating potential for corruption. Punishments included amputation for theft and execution for serious crimes, applied inconsistently based on status and bribes. Alongside Islamic law, traditional dispute resolution involved ordeal testing (drinking poison, trial by water) to determine guilt, blending Islamic and indigenous justice systems.

14. Constant Existential Threat by Neighboring Kingdoms: Kingdoms existed in a state of perpetual tension and occasional warfare with neighboring realms, always preparing for invasion or retaliation.  The Inca faced constant threats from unconquered Amazonian tribes and rival pre-conquest factions seeking autonomy.

15. Buffer of Small Kingdoms Between Large Kingdoms: Smaller kingdoms often served as buffers or pawns between larger powers, their loyalties shifting according to immediate survival needs. The Balkans saw the Serbian Kingdom (under Stefan Dušan) and others act as buffers between Ottoman and Hungarian empires, their survival dependent on playing rivals against each other. 

16. Relationship by Marriage to Neighboring and Enemy Kingdoms: Political marriages served as tools for alliances, peace treaties, or deceit, interlinking royal families across often hostile borders.  Chinese dynasties married princesses to hostile tribes' leaders to secure temporary peace (like Han princess marriages to Xiongnu leaders). 

17. Problem Groups: The socially marginalized were labeled as problematic mainly because they threatened the power structures, not necessarily due to inherent problematic behavior.  In Ottoman Balkans, Christian populations were classified as dhimmis (protected but subordinate minorities), labeled as potential troublemakers.

18. Migration and Refugee Influx Due to War: Warfare in neighboring kingdoms caused displacement, with refugees flowing into more stable realms, adding strain to resources and social order. The Mamluk defeat of the Mongols—especially the famous Battle of ʿAyn Jālūt (1260)—was indeed strongly aided by refugees, particularly Khwarazmian, Kipchak, and other Turkic steppe migrants fleeing the Mongol invasions.

19. External Invasion: Glory and Trauma: The threat or onslaught of a powerful, nomadic conqueror reminiscent of Genghis Khan radically altered the political, social, and psychological landscape of affected kingdoms. The memory of such overwhelming conquest lived on in folklore, shaping hero myths, and ongoing cycles of vengeance or submission. Similarly, Franks under Charles Martel stopped the Umayyads at the Battle of Tours (732).

20Rise of Cult Movement: Religious/Magical cults gained traction by promising salvation, divine favor, or power to disenfranchised populations and soldiers, especially amid instability.   The cult's leaders sometimes claimed exclusive access to divine truth, thereby labeling rivals as heretics or enemies.  From the Roman perspective, Christianity was the cult.

21. Schisms and Patronage: Competing sects or heretical movements challenged established religions, sometimes sparking wars or secret alliances. Rulers often used religious patronage to legitimize their rule, while diverse and sometimes conflicting religious movements influenced social cohesion and political alliances.  The Catholic Church and Eastern Orthodox Church broke communion during the East–West Schism of 1054

22Pilgrimage: Pilgrims traveled vast distances to sacred sites—holy shrines of legendary saints or deities, or places believed to possess miraculous powers. These journeys created distinctive political dynamics that enriched narrative possibilities. Pilgrimage could serve as cover for political refugees or criminals seeking absolution and new identities. Even, Mali's Mansa Musa's 1324 pilgrimage to Mecca became legendary for its extravagance and political importance, with his journey establishing Mali's legitimacy in the Islamic world.

23. Non-Violent Movements: Historical societies also developed sophisticated non-violent resistance movements that challenged power structures through spiritual authority, moral witness, and organized non-compliance. Buddhism emerged in ancient India as a direct challenge to Vedic Brahminical hierarchy. Buddhist monasteries (sanghas) became alternative power centers, attracting millions of adherents including lower castes, women, and merchants excluded from Brahminical privileges. 

24. Ancient Ruins and Forgotten Knowledge: Lost civilizations and ancient artifacts provided mysterious power and motives central to quests or conflicts. The Inca deliberately incorporated pre-Conquest Inca ruins (like Tiwanaku temples) into their ideology, claiming to inherit mystical power and legitimacy from earlier civilizations. Machu Picchu and other Inca sites were believed to hold astronomical and spiritual knowledge guiding imperial decisions.

25. Religious Transformation and Temple Destruction: Across world history, religions and empires have often replaced each other’s symbols or sacred sites. Iconoclasm is the belief in the importance of the destruction of icons and monuments, often for religious or political reasons. Hindu populations under Islamic sultanates-maintained temple worship and ritual practices despite official pressure for conversion and destruction of sacred sites


Thursday, November 20, 2025

Book Review: India's War - The Making of Modern South Asia, 1939-1945 by Srinath Raghavan


⭐⭐⭐⭐✰ Worth Reading


A French writer once asked: What made France a nation? He listed three factors – the French educational system, the French Army, and the French middle classes. In the Indian context, the Second World War served as a crucible for nation-making through different mechanisms. 
This is well documented in the book, India's War: The Making of Modern South Asia, 1939-1945. The book is an essential read for anyone interested in India’s involvement in World War II. Covering key wars and military operations, the book sheds light on the evolution of India's armed force & it’s the political, economic, monetary, and social impact on the nation.

The war mobilized over 2.5 million Indian soldiers between 1939 to 1945, and India underwent an extraordinary and irreversible change due to World War II. Hundreds of thousands of Indians suddenly found themselves in uniform, fighting in a global conflict. The book explains how the Indian Army evolved during World War II. Initially, the army was a colonial force serving British interests. But by the end of the war, the army had become a skilled and powerful fighting force. Indian soldiers fought in important battles across North Africa, Italy, the Middle East, and Southeast Asia. When Srinath Raghavan covers legendary battles of Imphal & Kohima, he dives into the heart of the battles and shows his military chops.

During World War II, the Indian National Congress (INC) first fought against British rule with peaceful protests, led by Mahatma Gandhi. In 1942, they started the Quit India Movement, asking the British to leave India immediately. The Congress did not support the war unless they were consulted. Despite this, many Indian soldiers and workers—over two and a half million—joined the war effort. The author establishes how the rise of the Muslim League and de-mobilization of the army veterans post 1945 and heightened tensions between Hindu-Muslims eventually led to India’s Partition. The author deserves praise for explaining all this so well.

The book highlights the Indian National Army (INA)  took a different approach and led India’s fight for independence under Subhas Chandra Bose. The INA fought alongside Japan against the British to liberate India. The book’s detailed discussion of Burma Campaign also offers an interesting lens on how Bose’s vision of armed resistance gained traction among some sectors of Indian society, even though the INA faced defeat.

The British Raj, which controlled India, was more than just a colonial entity during World War II. The book shows how the British Raj functioned like a "mini empire" of its own and became a vital part of the British Empire's war strategy.  The book clearly explains the urgent demands of military modernization and the wartime governance. 

The book also explores lesser-known aspects of the war economy explaining the heavy economic exploitation by the British government and yet the foundation for future industrial growth in India after the war. The British used Indian resources (both manpower and materials) to support their war efforts. While industries grew to support the war, rural India continued to suffer from poverty, hunger, and inflation.

India served as a major base for U.S. operations, receiving machinery, munitions, textiles, steel production equipment, locomotives, and various supplies to support Allied forces in the Burma-China-India theater.  The book shows how industrialization leads to creation of new working-class in India.  The author highlights that the war put a lot of economic pressure on India and showed conflicts in British rule. This pushed different groups in India to come together with a shared hope for independence. 

At times, the dense historical detail in the book may challenge casual readers, but it rewards those seeking depth. Beyond recounting South Asian history, the book compels readers to reflect on the war efforts and political transformation of India.  The book stands out as a compelling account of World War II from Indian perspective, offering both historical depth and political economy insights.

Sunday, November 16, 2025

Book Review: Among the Believers: An Islamic Journey

Among the Believers: An Islamic Journey by V. S. Naipaul

⭐⭐⭐⭐✰ Worth Reading

History bears out the proposition that political revolutions have always been preceded by social and religious revolutions. 
 In Bangladesh, a significant number of people have converted to Islam over centuries, particularly during the medieval period when the region was influenced by conquest of Muslim rulers and proselytization by Sufi saints.

Today, there has been the rapid rise of radicalism in Bangladesh with the ouster of ex-Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina in the student protest.  The protest has now been hijacked by Islamic extremists. Over the years, there was a surge in madrasas, and this has led to growing religious fanaticism, with zealots aggressively pushing an Islamist agenda. With Islamist influence in power, Bangladesh is modifying national identity by erasing symbols of its secular past, including the removal of statues of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman and attacking Hindu minority. 

The explanation about such rapid religious radicalism of Bangladesh or any more such converted societies is relevant to book published in 1981, Among the Believers: An Islamic Journey by the Nobel laureate V. S. Naipaul. The book is a controversial and critical travelogue in nature. The book describes a six-month journey across the Asian continent after the Iranian Revolution across Iran, Pakistan, Malaysia and Indonesia. These countries were originally Zoroastrian, Buddhist, Hindu and pagan. The history of these nations is built on conquest and conversion where a diverse and cutting-edge center of learning and trade during its time become engulfed by Islamic ideology. Through interviews and personal observations, Naipaul effort to understand societies conquered by Islam and the religious zeal gripping youth in these societies. The theme of the book is a study of capturing deep cultural and political shifts in the Muslim world post Iranian revolution. 

The author explains the crux of Islamic extremism as a form of ideological imperialism that denies the complex histories and cultures of converted peoples. The people who converted to Islam were encouraged to act like Arabs and follow their strict ways. The descendent of these converts started to forget and ignore their own rich history and culture. In the minds of these believers, being conquered by the Arabs and becoming like them is still seen as a way to be saved.

Naipaul observed that before 1979, there was two simultaneous spark of revolutions in Iran—communist and Islamic—both driven by utopianism. Naipaul visits Iran shortly after the success of Islamic Revolution. The revolution against Shah gained broad support to Ayatollah by promising a return to traditional values and social justice based on religion. After the revolution, Iran became an Islamic Republic, and communism lost influence in the country. Naipaul depicts a nation living through a dystopian dream. Although the official rhetoric had changed, the torture and executions didn't stop.  

Naipaul travels to Pakistan and make sweeping conclusion. He notes that Pakistan was born amid sectarian bloodshed and political chaos. Within a decade, the fragile democracy was overtaken by military rule, following the hanging of Pakistan’s prime minister in a coup three years earlier. Much attention in the book is drawn to the Muslim invasion of the Indian subcontinent, especially the Arab conquest of Sindh, which Naipaul describes as a foundational event shaping the collective psyche. Naipaul highlights how this narrative of conquest is seen by many in Pakistan and Bangladesh as a moment of salvation and religious dominance continues to fuel political Islam in contemporary Pakistan. 

Naipaul further travels to Malayasia and Indonesia situated in South-east Asia. Naipaul further describes Malaysia as a place where Islam initially blended easily with local customs and beliefs, creating a mixed or syncretic faith. However, this changed as missionaries arrived from Pakistan aiming to purify Islam and make it more orthodox. Many young Malays who studied abroad came back to their villages calling for stricter religious observance. 

Regarding Indonesia, Naipaul notes its history of cultural influence by Hinduism and Buddhism but highlights how youth movements sparked widespread Islamic conversions. Today, about 90% of Indonesians are Muslim. While Indonesia is constitutionally secular, religion plays a strong role the legal systems and the application of sharia law are common concerns.

Naipaul identifies Islam as a political and social system in ways other religions are not by delivering few strong messages. One, Islam’s message of equality often drew in poor and marginalized communities looking for dignity. Two, many converts saw Islam as a way to resist the dominance of traditional power. And three, by asking converts to reject their pre-Islamic past, the Islam turn them into more passionate believers than native Arabs themselves.

Jihad does not spring due to the lack of economic or social upliftment but their plain and simple aim of degrading the secular state and establishing sharia rule. Naipaul explains that Islamic extremism often arises among young people searching for identity, influenced by madarsa education and a desire for pure faith, yet it also creates conflict with ideas of modernity, culture, and politics. The brilliance of the book is in showing how extremism grew in some Islamic societies during the 1970s. Irrespective of personal expectations, this is no doubt an important book, but only as a starting point.  Highly recommended reading for the persons interested in Islamic societies. 

Friday, November 14, 2025

Book Review: Mera Dagistan by Rasul Gamzatov

My Dagestan (Мой Дагестан) (Avar: Дир Дагъистан) by Rasul Gamzatov.

The book was translated in English in 1970 by Julius Katzer and Dorian Rottenberg.

⭐⭐⭐⭐✰ Worth Reading

Let me speak of Dagestan—a rugged land along North Caucasus of Eastern Europe and the western shore of the Caspian Sea. The word Dagestan is of Turkish and Persian origin, directly translating to "land of the mountains".  The land has for centuries been a mosaic of peoples and languages: Avars, Dargins, Lezgins, Laks, Kumyks, and many others. The territory was annexed into the Russian Empire after protracted wars in the early nineteenth century.  By 1921, with the Red Army’s advance, the Dagestan Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic came into being. 

Soviet state enforced sweeping modernization in Dagestan, bringing it into line with Marxist-Leninist ideology while managing the religious sentiments. Arabic was replaced first by Latin, later by Cyrillic; schools sprang up, teaching not scripture but secular education. The writers urged to craft a modern national literature that must reflect Soviet ideals like progress, collective ownership, brotherhood and unity. A strange paradox took root—Islam receded under official suspicion, but ethnic and linguistic self-awareness unexpectedly thrived.

Out of this creative ferment emerged Rasul Gamzatov (1923–2003), the poet whom Dagestan now claims as its voice in the Avar languageGamzatov’s literary voice reflects a deep connection to his roots, and his writings offer profound insights into the history, traditions, and people of Dagestan. His masterpiece, My Dagestan (1967), celebrates the Caucasian folklore and expresses a deep belonging to his native land. 

The book draws multiple anecdotes from lives of five personalities: Ahmed Khan Abu-Bakar – a prominent Soviet writer of the Dargin people, Gamzat Tsadasy – his father and a well-known folk poet, Abutalib Gafurovich Gafurov – a Lakian poet of Dagestan, Imam Shamil and Hadji Murad– legendary Avar leaders who symbolize the spiritual and military resistance of the North Caucasus.

Gamzatov’s narrative style is generous and warm. He took care to introduce the names and stories of Dagestani people, ensuring they were remembered. Through anecdotes, jokes, and verses, he painted vivid pictures of Dagestan’s natural beauty and cultural richness. His book is a unique literary work that blends poetry and prose, oral traditions, folklore and criticism, and gossip while functioning as both a cultural history of Dagestani poetry and a personal philosophical testament. 

Today, West is struggling to narrow down the essential characteristics of Muslim identity – is it primarily culture, religion, ethnicity? But cultures are heterogeneous and contradictory, highly porous, and deeply intertwined.  A key aspect of the book is the reflection of Dagestan’s cultural hybridity—where Soviet ideals, pre-Islamic (pagan) traditions, and Islamic values intersect and merge, creating a unique and layered cultural identity. In this book, Gamzatov demonstrated remarkable knowledge not only of Dagestani literature, but also of Soviet & North Caucasian literary traditions and personalities.

For readers seeking a poetic journey through history, poetry, and human connection of a distant land, this book is an unforgettable experience. For the readers seeking a profound understanding of culture of Soviet era Dagestan, this book is an invaluable resource. Rasul Gamzatov doesn’t just tell the story of Dagestan — he makes the readers feel like a part of it. 

*The poem, Zhuravli (english translation) by Rasul Gamzatov has become a well-known Soviet song.

Wednesday, November 12, 2025

Book Review: Bhutan: The Kingdom at the Centre of the World by Omair Ahmad

Bhutan: The Kingdom at the Centre of the World by Omair Ahmad

⭐⭐⭐⭐✰ Worth Reading

Despite the neighboring state of India, relatively limited number of books for common readers are available on Bhutan, a landlocked country in the Eastern Himalayas. This can be attributed to unique geography and isolation a policy of self-imposed isolation, which was successful in preserving its territorial integrity as a Himalayan kingdom. Bhutan is much less known in the U.S. and western hemisphere that too for its Buddhism and as a mystical, serene travel destination. Bhutan is slowly gaining popularity as a travel destination and the readers will know a surprising fact on reading the book connecting Bhutan with the 'Golden Gate Bridge' of San Francisco.

Omair Ahmad has written an insightful and beautiful book into the history of Bhutan, Druk Yul: Land of the Thunder Dragon. The book is beautifully researched, with the most relevant information and this book will be of particular interest to scholars, and students of the history & culture.  

The author dives into the transition of the Buddhist Kingdom from a vassal state of Tibet to a fully independent country. Bhutan's kings fought primarily against Tibetan invasions in the 17th century and later lost territory to British India in the 1864-65 Duar War. They also had border conflicts with Sikkim and internal power struggles before establishing the monarchy in 1907.

The author takes us into the intermingling journey of people living in the porous boundaries of Tibet, Nepal, Sikkim, British India, and Bhutan without getting into the complexity of the geopolitical wars.  Once the border of Bhutan was settled in the 1950s, history becomes more interesting with a variety of characters, annexation of Sikkim in India and the politics of the creation of an international profile of Bhutan monarchy. 

Since Bhutan is sandwiched between hungry empires, the country has learned to maintain a delicate balance and customers. between them. The book shows why Bhutan is so important to truly understanding the ongoing relationship between India and China that was proven in Doklam conflict in 2017.

The book doesn’t shy away from tough topics either, like the Nepali refugee crisis and Bhutan’s experiments with democracy. Through these incidents, you get a sense of how this small but significant Himalayan nation is carving out its own unique path amid big regional changes.

The books touch lightly on the effect of modern civilization on Buddhist traditions, culture & heritage. Bhutan has been doing a delicate balancing act between tradition and modernization. The book becomes more engaging with the personal travel experiences and observations of the author. Omair Ahmad has a very engaging style of writing, which helps the readers to race through the book. We should be thankful to Shetty for undertaking this rather difficult task and bringing out the output in such an easy and readable and referable format.

There’s no better way to experience the quiet paradise of Bhutan before touring than reading out this book. Read the book to know of nation with a mythic backdrop of Buddhism in which old traditional values struggle against stronger modern forces in the world.