Book Review - Goa, 1961 by Valmiki Faleiro | Goodreads

⭐⭐⭐⭐✰ Worth Reading



In Mahabharata (Sanskrit epic of ancient India revered in Hinduism), Lord Krishna exhausted every path of peace before the failure of negotiation leads the Pandavas and Kauravas towards the great war—theKurukshetra War. Jawaharlal Nehru (Indian Primem Minister 1947- 1964), however, was a mere mortal, restrained by his idealistic commitment to non-violence, diplomacy and international opinion. His reluctance allowed Portuguese rule in Goa to continue for nearly fourteen years after India’s independence. This long hesitation forms the moral and political tension at the heart of Goa, 1961, a detailed and well-researched account of Goa’s liberation and integration with India.

The book goes far beyond the thirty six hours military narrative often associated with December 1961. It traces Goan nationalism, the sacrifices of freedom fighters, the repression of the Portuguese secret police, India’s diplomatic dilemmas and the final military action. Its strength lies in rejecting convenient binaries: not every Portuguese official was cruel, not every Goan supported liberation, and not every action taken after liberation was beyond criticism.

Yet, beyond the conflict with Portugal, Goa appears gripped by a collective political fever: its people unsettled, its atmosphere tense and its aspirations pulled in competing directions by uncertainty, identity and political jockeying. The book also restores Goan nationalism to the centre of the liberation narrative. It shows that resistance to Portuguese rule developed within Goa through the work of freedom fighters, political organisations, writers and ordinary citizens.

Liberation ended colonial rule, but it did not settle the question of what Goa would become. The book also delves into later struggle to preserve Konkani, Goan identity and political distinctiveness shows that integration was a continuing process, not a single military event.

Political Battles

For Jawaharlal Nehru, Goa created an agonising contradiction. India had championed non-violence, decolonisation and peaceful settlement, yet Portugal refused negotiation while suppressing Goan nationalism. Nehru exhausted years in diplomacy before concluding that force had become unavoidable, making Goa both a test of his principles and a decisive moment in the unfinished global struggle against colonialism.

A sharply drawn profile of António de Oliveira Salazar helps explain Portugal’s extraordinary intransigence. Governing an impoverished and authoritarian country, Salazar treated Goa not simply as territory but as proof that Portugal remained an imperial power. His order to resist to the last man, and even contemplate a scorched-earth response, reveals a regime more concerned with imperial symbolism than with Goan lives. 



The Western response exposed its own hypocrisy. After years of restraint, Nehru was suddenly mocked as “Bandit Nehru” instead of “Pandit Nehru,” while a British newspaper called him a “sanctimonious bully.” The man criticised for waiting too long was now condemned for acting, as defenders of the colonial order scrutinised the means of liberation more harshly than colonialism itself.

Historical Background

Goa’s Indo-Portuguese society was itself a product of deliberate colonial policy. After Vasco da Gama’s arrival in 1498, Afonso de Albuquerque encouraged marriages between Portuguese men and local women through his Política dos Casamentos (Policy of Marriages) seeking to create a locally rooted population loyal to Portuguese authority. The policy contributed to the emergence of a distinctive Indo-Portuguese society, although cultural intermingling did not transform colonial domination into political consent.

Writing as a Goan deeply familiar with the region’s social history, Faleiro revisits the Goa Inquisition, one of the darkest chapters of Portuguese rule. The religious authority became an instrument of coercion, persecution and cultural erasure. Conversions were accompanied by restrictions on local customs, confiscation of property and pressure on communities to abandon older beliefs. Yet resistance also came from within the Church. The Pinto Revolt of 1787, involving Goan clergy and local elites, revealed that shared Christianity did not translate into equality under Portuguese rule. 

Conclusion

One limitation is that the book could have explored more fully the wider consequences of Goa’s liberation: its psychological effect on anti-colonial movements in Angola, Mozambique and Portuguese Guinea, and the blow it delivered to Salazar’s authority within Portugal. The fall of Goa exposed the fragility of the Portuguese empire and foreshadowed the colonial wars that ultimately exhausted the Estado Novo.

The book’s abundance of military and documentary detail occasionally slows its movement, yet the same depth makes it one of the most valuable accounts of Goa’s liberation and integration. It presents 1961 as the end of foreign rule and the beginning of another demanding task: integrating Goa into India without erasing the layered identity that history had created. For readers of Goan and modern Indian history, it is demanding but rewarding reading, fully deserving of four stars.

Comments

What are people reading?

Kanpur Coaching Gurus

Lyrics of Title Song from Bharat Ek Khoj

Kanpur Coaching Mandi

Kanpur Coaching Days

Book Review - Open Veins of Latin America by Eduardo Galeano